so he can only meet her after he drops off the kids, kisses the wife goodbye and has a few hours before he starts his busy Friday at the dealership. An appoint does not sound romantic, does it? It sound more like a liaison of an unscrupulous married man who compartmentalized his life.

Come on she has left on Wednesday but does not meet her man until Friday at a time that he has apparently arranged to fit in his schedule. She is going from one controlling situation and her naivete of this fact is laid bare by the appointment she made, one can only hope she has not burned her safety net, for a nefarious rendezvous. In she, it is an unnamed daughter who while she is well provided, feels abject loneliness and sees no future in her life with her parents, so she seeks a relationship with a an obvious huckster (what are car salesman to most of us but wolfs looking for prey to satisfy their quotas- car sales or sexual encounters does it mater to them) the ungentlemanly manner of her suitor is so sad, he cannot meet the parents properly and engage her in a relationship that involves her family. More importantly and similar to Eleanor Rigby is the loneliness experienced by the story's main character. Which devastates the clinging mother and her husband/daddy. The significant thing in the plot that makes the song incredibly sad is that the parent's do not get to say goodbye.

The harpist even said in interviews it was the most difficult piece to play and had to be overdubbed with a duplicate recording to give it the power it needed.

It takes an incredibly gifted songwriter and producer to take chamber music and turn it into a rock instrumentation. first thank you for putting together this list however, I feel you missed the plot line of 'She is Leaving' and the importance of making a pop rock ballad without a four piece band lead by an emotive harp and string orchestration, Scott Walker's arrangement while emotive pop orchestrations are not rock songs.

Tell me why you cried beatles